Japan Elections: Beware of USD/JPY U-Turn

Posted on

It is not often that we see the Yen move on Japanese fundamentals because but over the past month, Japan’s currency has weakened significantly in anticipation of a major leadership change. In order to receive support from the opposition party for a key financing bill that would allow Japan to issue new bonds to cover its spending, Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda dissolved Parliament and agreed to early elections this weekend on December 16th. Unfortunately there is a very good chance that this decision will lead to a loss of power by the ruling Democratic Party of Japan and the loss of a job for the Prime Minister. Japan’s Liberal Democratic Party, which ruled for half a century before the DPJ win in 2009 is widely expected to regain power with former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe leading the country once again. Opinion polls show the LDP winning with a two-thirds majority. 480 seats in the Lower House are up for grabs and Abe’s party would need to win at least 241 seats to have a majority but winning 320 seats or more would allow them to pass bills in the Lower House without support from the Upper House, which is huge.

While the Japanese Yen fell to a fresh 4 year low against the New Zealand dollar and 19th month low against the British pound and Canadian dollar during the Tokyo session, the currency is now higher across the board as traders take profits ahead of the weekend. By now, everyone should know that Shinzo Abe’s publicly vocal attack on the Bank of Japan is the main reason why the Yen has sold off aggressively. The LDP leader has demanded the Bank of Japan adopt a higher 2% inflation target and to print money continuously to achieve this goal. With annualized inflation currently at -0.4%, this demand basically translates into an open ended commitment to easy monetary policy. If the BoJ fails to comply, Abe has also threatened to strip away their independence. These outrageous claims have made Abe extremely power with a country that has grown increasingly frustrated with persistent deflation and 20 years of zero growth.

Beware of a U-Turn in USD/JPY

Yet considering that most investors expect Shinzo Abe to win, there’s a strong risk of a buy the rumor, sell the news type of reaction in USD/JPY. In other words, rather than extending lower, the Yen could actually rally if Abe wins. According to the CFTC’s Commitment of Traders report, short Yen or long USD/JPY positions were at their highest level since July 2007. While we have seen these positions reach even greater extremes in 2006, whenever we hit extreme levels over the past 2 years as shown in the chart below (white line = IMM positioning, gold line = USD/JPY), USD/JPY topped out shortly thereafter. A perfect fundamental catalyst for a U-Turn in USD/JPY would be back peddling by Shinzo Abe. He may have ran on a campaign of greater pressure on the BoJ, but it wouldn’t be the first time that a politician has backtracked on campaign promises. Also at the beginning of this month, Abe hinted that he could reduce pressure on the BoJ once he takes office. In a debate with Party Leaders, he said, “If I become prime minister, I will not comment on specific monetary policy measures, which should be decided by the Bank of Japan, I am commenting on specific measures because I am in opposition.” BoJ Governor Shirakawa’s term also ends his 5 year term in April of next year at which point Abe will have an opportunity to nominate a candidate who is more willing to ease. In other words, with only 4 months left in Shirakawa’s term, Abe may choose to wait and not force a change in BoJ law that would risk infuriating business leaders if he can put in place a BoJ Governor that supports his view. Abe cannot “appoint” a BoJ Governor but he can nominate a candidate that needs to be approved by the Lower and Upper Houses. While a U-Turn in USD/JPY could flush out many short Yen traders, leading to a sharp reversal in the currency pair, when the dust settles, monetary policy still needs to become easier because growth remains very weak.

Kathy Lien
Managing Director

2 thoughts on “Japan Elections: Beware of USD/JPY U-Turn”

  1. When you say, “the Yen could actually rally,” do you mean it could get “stronger,” therefore with a lower number than 83? In other words, the yen is currently quoted at about 83. “Rallying” therefore means it may go back down toward 80 or 78? I’m not looking for a prediction; I’m looking for the ironic inverse definition of “rallying” in a currency vs rallying of a stock, which implies the stock price to go higher. If the yen goes from 83 to 80, that is going lower. I understand that it is against another currency, but how does one play forex here? Assuming we hold to the concept that the yen will, in fact, rally, do I then want to SELL the USD/JPY????

    I’m confused. Please explain.

  2. Hi Kathy,

    I’ve been following some of your twits/publications for some time now (about 2 years). I just want to say that your insights are very intersting and full of fundamental macro views, but most of the time,your short term market views are wrong. I’ve tried recently to trade against your views and that’s when I made good money. So, I’m not saying for your to stop, just go on and I’ll be taking the opposite view. Just sold all JPY crosses last Friday. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *